In Poland, the job interview process is subject to strict legal regulations aimed at preventing discrimination and ensuring equal treatment of candidates. The country’s labor laws, particularly the Labor Code (Kodeks Pracy) and the Anti-Discrimination Law, protect job applicants from being asked personal questions that have no bearing on their ability to perform the job. Understanding these laws can help both employers and candidates ensure that interviews remain professional, fair, and focused on qualifications, skills, and experience.
This guide will outline the types of illegal job interview questions in Poland, explain why they are inappropriate, and offer advice for both candidates and employers on how to navigate these situations.
Why are some questions illegal?
Poland’s labor laws are designed to prevent discrimination in the workplace, both during recruitment and throughout employment. The Labor Code explicitly prohibits discrimination based on:
- Gender
- Age
- Race
- Religion
- Nationality
- Disability
- Political beliefs
- Sexual orientation
- Marital status or family responsibilities
The main purpose of the laws is to ensure that job candidates are evaluated based on their qualifications, work experience, and ability to perform the duties required for the role, rather than on personal characteristics that have no relation to the job.
Asking inappropriate or illegal questions during an interview could lead to biased decision-making, which is why the Polish legal framework clearly defines what can and cannot be asked. If candidates feel they have been asked discriminatory questions, they have the right to file a complaint with the National Labor Inspectorate (Państwowa Inspekcja Pracy), or pursue legal action for discriminatory practices.
Candidates should know their rights
During the recruitment process, it is crucial that the questions posed to candidates align with job requirements and comply with legal regulations. Questions regarding national origin, ethnic origin, number of children, criminal history, or trade union membership are considered illegal interview questions and violate the personal rights of candidates. Employers must avoid asking questions that are irrelevant to the job or assessing the suitability of a candidate for the position. Every candidate has the right to refuse to answer questions they deem an invasion of their privacy.
Employers must ensure that the questions asked during an interview relate directly to the nature of the job and the requirements of the job and are essential for assessing the candidate’s ability to perform the duties of the role. According to federal and state law, such discriminatory questions are unlawful and can lead to significant consequences for the employer, including burden of proof of non-discrimination.
Candidates should know their rights throughout the job search process and recognize which questions an employer may not legally ask. Employers should avoid asking about sensitive personal information, such as social origin, religion, or membership in professional organizations, unless regulated by law and required in specific circumstances.
The questions asked during an interview have a profound impact on establishing an employment relationship and ensuring that the recruitment process adheres to non-discrimination laws. Employers must focus on questions relevant to assessing the professional qualifications and suitability of the candidate for the performance of the job. Updating recruitment practices to avoid unlawful questions and asking only questions relevant to the job requirements is vital for maintaining a fair and compliant hiring process that respects candidates’ personal rights.
Employers generally have the right to ask questions that are relevant to assessing the qualifications and suitability of the candidate for the job, but they also cannot ask about topics that are irrelevant to the employment relationship. Hiring decisions must be based on professional qualifications, suitability for the job, and the requirements of the employment contract. By adhering to privacy policies and ensuring questions are lawful, employers contribute to a positive job market and fair employment practices.
Questions about age
Discrimination based on age is prohibited by Polish labor law. While an employer can ask for your age once you’re hired for administrative purposes, it is illegal to ask about your age during the recruitment process as it can lead to age-related bias. This is especially relevant for older candidates or those nearing retirement age.
- Illegal Question: “How old are you?” or “What year were you born?”
- Why It’s Illegal: Such questions could lead to discrimination based on age, potentially excluding older candidates.
- Legal Alternative: Employers can ask, “Are you over 18?” if the job legally requires workers to be of a certain age.
Questions about marital status or family life
Asking about a candidate’s personal life, such as their marital status or family planning, is considered discriminatory, especially toward women, as it can lead to assumptions about their availability or commitment to the job. Employers cannot legally ask whether you are married, have children, or plan to have children in the future.
- Illegal Questions:
- “Are you married?”
- “Do you have any children?”
- “Are you planning to start a family soon?”
- Why It’s Illegal: These questions may lead to gender discrimination, as employers might unfairly assume that a candidate with children or plans to start a family might not be as dedicated to their job.
- Legal Alternative: None. Employers cannot legally ask about your personal or family situation as it has no bearing on job performance.
Questions about religion
Religion is a deeply personal matter, and questions related to religious beliefs or practices are illegal under Polish labor law. Employers cannot inquire about your religious affiliation or whether you observe specific religious holidays, as this may lead to religious discrimination.
- Illegal Question: “What religion do you practice?” or “Do you observe any religious holidays?”
- Why It’s Illegal: Asking about religion can lead to bias based on religious beliefs, which is protected under Polish anti-discrimination laws.
- Legal Alternative: None. Religious beliefs should not be discussed during the recruitment process.
Job interviews questions about political beliefs
Political views are another protected area under Polish labor law. Employers are not allowed to inquire about your political affiliations or beliefs, as these questions can lead to discrimination based on your political ideology.
- Illegal Question: “What political party do you support?”
- Why It’s Illegal: Asking about political beliefs can lead to discrimination or bias based on personal ideology, which has no relevance to job performance.
- Legal Alternative: None. Political opinions are irrelevant to employment qualifications.
Questions about gender or sexual orientation
In Poland, questions regarding a candidate’s gender identity or sexual orientation are strictly prohibited. These characteristics are protected under anti-discrimination laws, and employers cannot ask about a candidate’s sexual preferences or relationships.
- Illegal Questions:
- “Are you gay/straight?”
- “Do you have a partner or spouse?”
- Why It’s Illegal: Asking about sexual orientation or gender identity can lead to discrimination based on the candidate’s private life, which is unrelated to their ability to perform the job.
- Legal Alternative: None. Sexual orientation should never be a topic of discussion during a job interview.
Questions about health or disabilities
Employers cannot ask about a candidate’s health conditions or disabilities unless it is directly related to their ability to perform essential job functions. Even then, questions should be carefully framed to avoid discrimination. Polish law ensures that people with disabilities are protected and provided with reasonable accommodations when necessary.
- Illegal Questions:
- “Do you have any health problems?”
- “Have you been hospitalized recently?”
- Why It’s Illegal: These questions may lead to discrimination against candidates with disabilities or health issues, even if they are fully capable of performing the job.
- Legal Alternative: Employers can ask, “Are you able to perform the essential duties of the job with or without reasonable accommodations?” if the job requires specific physical or mental abilities.
Questions about nationality, ethnicity, or race
Questions about a candidate’s nationality, race, or ethnic background are illegal, as they could lead to racial or ethnic discrimination. While employers can ask if a candidate is legally authorized to work in Poland (especially for non-EU nationals), they cannot inquire into their ethnic or racial identity.
- Illegal Questions:
- “Where are you from?”
- “What is your ethnicity?”
- Why It’s Illegal: Questions about nationality or ethnicity may be used to discriminate against candidates based on race or origin, which is prohibited by law.
- Legal Alternative: Employers may ask, “Are you legally authorized to work in Poland?” to ensure compliance with immigration laws.
Questions about criminal record
In Poland, employers are not allowed to ask about a candidate’s criminal record unless the position requires it (e.g., jobs in law enforcement or positions of trust). Even in these cases, the question must be relevant to the job role.
- Illegal Question: “Have you ever been convicted of a crime?”
- Why It’s Illegal: Asking about criminal history may unfairly disadvantage candidates with past convictions that are not relevant to the job.
- Legal Alternative: In cases where a clean criminal record is necessary, employers can state upfront that the position requires a background check and ask if the candidate is comfortable with that process.
Questions about residence or living situation
Employers cannot ask about a candidate’s housing situation, such as whether they rent or own their home, as this is irrelevant to job performance. However, they can ask whether a candidate is willing to relocate if the job requires it.
- Illegal Question: “Do you rent or own your home?”
- Why It’s Illegal: Questions about personal living arrangements can be discriminatory and are unrelated to the candidate’s ability to do the job.
- Legal Alternative: Employers can ask, “Are you willing to relocate if the position requires it?”
Questions about military service (in some cases)
Asking about a candidate’s past military service is illegal unless the position requires such experience (e.g., security jobs or roles that involve defense-related work). Otherwise, asking about military service can lead to discrimination based on age or past obligations.
- Illegal Question: “Did you serve in the military?”
- Why It’s Illegal: In some cases, asking about military service can be used to gauge a candidate’s age, which could lead to age-related discrimination.
- Legal Alternative: None, unless military experience is directly related to the job.
What if an employer asks illegal questions?
If you are asked an illegal question during a job interview in Poland, it’s important to remain calm and professional. You have several options for responding:
- Politely Refuse: You can politely decline to answer the question, saying something like, “I don’t believe that question is relevant to the job, but I’d be happy to discuss my qualifications.”
- Redirect the Conversation: You can steer the conversation back to your skills and experience, saying, “I’d prefer to focus on how my skills and experience can benefit the company.”
- Address It After the Interview: If you feel uncomfortable during the interview, you can address the issue afterward by contacting the company’s HR department or filing a complaint with the National Labor Inspectorate.
Conclusion questions are illegal
Poland’s labor laws aim to ensure that job interviews remain focused on qualifications, experience, and job-related skills. Employers are not allowed to ask questions that delve into personal matters such as age, marital status, religion, or health unless they are directly relevant to the job.
Candidates should feel empowered to recognize and respond appropriately to illegal questions during a job interview. Employers, on the other hand, must ensure their recruitment practices comply with the law to create a fair, inclusive, and non-discriminatory hiring process.
In the recruitment process, it is essential for both candidates and interviewers to understand the type of questions that are appropriate and lawful. There are specific questions that an employer may ask, and others that are illegal. Employers must be aware that questions related to a candidate’s criminal history, national origin, or personal information are often prohibited. It is important for candidates to know their rights and recognize when questions are unlawful or irrelevant to the position.
Interviewers should only ask questions that relate to the job and the candidate’s qualifications. Asking questions that may discriminate, such as those about trade union membership or social origin, is also illegal. Employers must ensure that the questions asked are relevant to the job requirements and do not infringe on the candidate’s privacy. There are exceptions to this rule, but they are strictly regulated by law.
Candidates have the right to refuse to answer questions they find irrelevant or intrusive, and they should understand that feedback is private and confidential. Employers may ask questions to assess the candidate’s ability to perform the role, but questions and understanding should remain focused on the professional aspects of the employment relationship. Application forms should be designed to gather information that is necessary for the job, while respecting the candidate’s personal rights. Employers should update their choices regarding interview practices to avoid unlawful inquiries.
During the recruitment process, employers and potential employers should ask the candidate to provide only the information relevant to assessing their suitability for the job. Employers’ views may vary, but the questions asked should always adhere to legal standards and respect the candidate’s rights. That;s why some questions are illegal. Remember, an employment relationship should be built on mutual respect, and hiring decisions should be made based on qualifications and suitability, rather than irrelevant personal details.
time2work
Are you curious about who we are? We are already in a hurry to answer. Time2work is a team of experts in legal employment in Poland. Every day we connect workers with Polish employers who provide decent conditions for legal work. Legal and transparent action on behalf of foreigners is of utmost importance to us. Thanks to this, anyone who finds a job with us will also find accommodation and help with organizational issues that are not easy to go through on your own. Are you looking for a job and opportunities to live in Poland? Check what we can offer you if you want be hire in Poland by a foreign employer! 94% of our workers extend the work contract with us. Apply for a new work now
Time2legal – administration help for foreigners
If you need help with formalities check offer Time2legal – they prepare documents for worker to live in Poland. Time2Legal is a company dedicated to assisting foreign individuals in obtaining the necessary documentation to live and work in Poland. They offer support in applying for a temporary residence card and help clients obtain a work permit for legal employment in Poland. With an office in Poland, they guide both employees of foreign companies and individuals looking to apply for a visa to work or study in the country.
Their expertise extends to those who wish to work in export services or need a freelance visa in Poland. Time2legal ensures that clients can legally reside in Poland. Allowing them to stay continuously and even travel within other Schengen countries. For those holding a long-stay or Type D visa, they assist in switching to a residency permit if needed.
